2024年6月13日发(作者:针绿凝)
International Scientific Colloquium
Modelling for Electromagnetic Processing
Hannover, March 24-26, 2003
Modeling in Industrial Silicon Wafer Manufacturing - From
Crystal Growth to Device Processes
Th. Wetzel, J. Virbulis
Abstract
Silicon wafer manufacturing is one of the key processes that determine the yield and the
profitability in semiconductor device production. The present paper gives an overview on vari-
ous applications for numerical modeling in the wafer manufacturing process. It starts with ther-
mal and convection models for the crystal growth process, both by the Czochralski (CZ) and
the Floating Zone (FZ) method. Within this field, in particular modeling of electromagnetic
field influence on melt flow has become an an indispensable means for the puller design and the
process development for both methods. A further chapter is devoted to model approaches for
predicting crystal defects, like grown-in voids, self-interstitial aggregates or oxygen
precipitates. The defect modeling connect the crystal growth directly to the device
manufacturing processes, as crystal defects may be detrimental or beneficial to microelectronic
devices, produced on the silicon wafer. A last chapter points briefly to more recent applications
of numerical modeling in auxiliary processes, like wafer heat treatment steps, epitaxial growth
or wafer cleaning.
Introduction
During the last five decades, the technology for growing silicon monocrystals from the
melt, and the subsequent manufacture of silicon wafers, have become highly developed. The
quality, purity and size of today's silicon crystals and wafers have reached an outstanding level.
However, it remains time consuming and expensive to develop new processes that meet the
crystal and wafer quality requirements for devices with further decreasing design rules. The
current transition to a wafer diameter of 300 mm creates further challenges for the wafer
industry.
One of the main driving forces for the use of numerical modeling in the wafer industry
are the extremely high costs for growth furnace design and growth process development.
Thermal simulation of the global heat transfer in crystal growth furnaces contributes substan-
tially to keeping the development costs at an acceptable level. In particular with the transition
to 300 mm diameter CZ crystal growth, magnetic fields have become an important additional
means to control heat and mass transfer in the large melt volumes. Numerical modeling
facilitates the suitable design of inductor systems and helps to understand the effect of the
magnetic fields on the melt flow. However, the growth conditions do not only affect yield or
pull rate, but also the quality of the crystals. Grown-in defects like voids, self-interstitial
aggregates or oxygen precipitates can be detrimental or beneficial in subsequent process steps.
Therefore, defect engineering, i.e. the control of the formation of such defects, is an important
part of the whole wafer production. Numerical modeling helps to predict the defect formation
and behavior through crystal growth and for subsequent process steps, up to the device
processes for microelectronic components in the chip manufacturer’s production line.
67
Beside the success of the crystal growth and the defect simulation, there is an
increasing number of new applications of numerical modeling in the wafer manufacturing
industry, e.g. in process steps like wafer polishing, epitaxial layer growth or wet cleaning of the
wafers.
1. Crystal Growth
There are two major methods for producing silicon monocrystals from the melt. With
the Czochralski (CZ) method, today crystals of up to 300 mm are grown. The Floating Zone
(FZ) technology is currently scaled up to grow 200 mm crystals.
1.1 Czochralski Growth
Fig. 1 shows a longitudinal cut through a CZ growth furnace. The prediction of the
temperature field in the whole furnace and in the crystal requires a global thermal simulation,
taking into account the heat transfer by
conduction, convection and radiation.
Software tools for the conduction and
radiation calculation along with the pre-
diction of the melt-crystal interface are avai-
lable from different institutes [1, 2, 3]. They
are based on 2D axisymmetric models, em-
ploy view factor approaches for the
radiation treatment and are based on the
Finite Element Method (FEM) or the Finite
Volume Method (FVM). Some of these
codes allow the reproduction of transient
growth processes [2].
With increasing melt volumes and
crystal diameters, the consideration of the
melt convection has become more im-
portant. The melt flow in large diameter CZ
crucibles - today diameters of up to 32” with
loads of up to 450 kg are used - is characte-
rized by time dependent, three dimensional
processes. The time needed for a fully
transient, three-dimensional simulation of
Fig. 1: Schematic layout of an industrial CZ
melt flow in a crucible of the mentioned size
puller and simulated temperature distribution
however, still prevents their application for
(left)
industrial engineering purposes. Therefore,
2D axisymmetric steady state models have been developed, that reproduce the most important
features of the 3D flow, but do still provide reasonably short calculation time [4, 5]. One of the
most critical parts in any CZ melt flow simulation, both 2D and 3D, is the consideration of
turbulence. The 2D simulation tools usually employ k-ε or LowRe k-ε or k-ω models. Such
tools require careful experimental verification and modification based on comparisons with
experiments [5, 6, 7]. A model proposed in [8] provided good agreement of the simulated
melt-crystal interface shapes with measured ones for 200 mm crystals. 3D time dependent
simulations with LES turbulence models [9] and simulations close to DNS [10, 11] are used to
further develop the understanding of the flow behavior and to improve less time consuming
simulation models. One goal of such attempts is the global modeling of oxygen transport in the
68
CZ furnace, which is extremely sensitive towards any lack of precision in the turbulence
modeling.
Another aspect, closely related to reliable melt flow prediction, is the modeling of
magnetic field influence. In 300 mm CZ growth, different types of alternating (AC) magnetic
fields as well as static (DC) magnetic fields are used. The incorporation of the melt flow
models into the global heat transfer simulation tools facilitates direct consideration of the effect
of such fields on the temperature distribution in the crystal and all coupled phenomena, like
point defect dynamics. A 2D axisymmetric model approach for the AC and DC magnetic field
effect on the silicon melt is described in [5]. The model has been verified with experimental
results from a CZ model setup with various magnetic fields [7, 12].
1.2 Floating Zone Growth
Fig. 2 shows a longitudinal cut
through an FZ growth setup [13]. For the
numerical simulation of Floating Zone
growth there is a complete model chain
necessary, starting with the prediction of the
phase boundaries at feed rod, molten zone
and crystal, based on RF field influence and
heat transfer [14]. A second part of the
model chain is covering the prediction of the
transient melt flow and heat transfer based on
2D [15] and 3D [16] approaches. Based on
the melt flow calculation results, the dopant
transport can be simulated, yielding finally
the macroscopic and microscopic resistivity
distributions in grown wafers. The current
development of 200 mm FZ crystal growth
processes has been substantially supported by
the use of such simulation models.
Beyond these applications, the
influence of additional low frequency
Fig. 2: Schematic layout of a Floating Zone
inductors has been modeled [14] and
setup with simulated features and FEM mesh
considerations about the stress induced dislocation generation have been started [17]. A
recently developed improved phase boundary simulation model is presented in [18].
3. Defect Modeling
There are different types of defects in silicon wafers, which are related to the crystal
growth conditions and the thermal history of the crystal and wafer. During the solidification
process, intrinsic point defects, namely vacancies and silicon self interstitials, are incorporated
into the crystal. These intrinsic point defects form grown-in defects during cooling down from
melting to room temperature. Impurity atoms can also be incorporated into the growing
crystal, later forming precipitates or other defects. The most common of these impurities is
oxygen, which is dissolved from the silica crucible in CZ processes and transported through the
melt to the crystallization front.
69
Three types of defects in CZ crystals will be
mentioned here specifically: grown-in octahedral voids [19]
formed by the aggregation of vacancies (Fig. 3), oxide
precipitates [20] and the OSF ring [19].
Whether vacancy or self-interstitial related defects
are found in a CZ crystal or crystal region, depends on the
value v/G in that region at the crystallization interface during
solidification (v being the pull rate, G the temperature
gradient at the solid/liquid interface) [19, 21]. In addition to
determining these quantities from the thermal simulation,
models are used to directly describe the point defect
dynamics, i.e. the diffusive and convective transport of these
defects during crystal growth as well as their annihilation by
recombination [22]. The combination of such simulation
Fig.3: Octahedral void in an
models with the thermal simulation results, in particular the
as-grown silicon crystal [19]
transient temperature field in the crystal, allows to design
the growth furnace and the growth process in such a way, that grown crystals show a desired
defect species.
Furthermore, especially for vacancy rich crystals, that are for the production
of memory chips, it is necessary to ensure a specific size and density of the grown-in voids.
Simulation models have been developed, that describe the formation of such defects from
vacancies [19]. The size of the grown in voids depends strongly on the cooling rate in a
specific temperature interval during cooling down. Therefore, these models do also need the
thermal history of the crystal as well as the results of the point defect models. Fig. 4 shows
simulated size distributions of voids in fast and slow cooled CZ crystals. The void formation
models are also used to predict the impact of wafer heat treatment steps on size and density of
the voids.
An important part of defect modeling is devoted to the behavior of oxygen in CZ
silicon. As oxide precipitates are used as centers for internal gettering [20], models have been
developed to predict the size and in particular the density of such defects in CZ crystals and
wafers [23]. Another well known defect phenomenon is the so called OSF ring, appearing on
the wafer surface after
wet oxidation. The
nature and formation
of the OSF ring has
been studied by many
authors (see [19] for
further ref.). How-
ever, there is ongoing
research activity in
this field, as there are
complex interactions
of oxygen precipi-
tation with other point
defects or impurity
atoms in the growing
crystal, e.g. Nitrogen,
Fig. 4: Simulated size distributions of voids in crystals with different
that the
cooling rates
width of the OSF ring
70
[24].
3. Modeling for Wafer Processing Steps
Following crystal growth, there are several process steps in a wafer production line. It
starts with cutting of the ingots, goes through slicing, etching, polishing and ends with final
cleaning of the wafers. Inbetween there can be several other steps like lapping, thermal
treatment or epitaxial layer growth. In particular in the areas of etching, cleaning and epitaxial
layer growth there are several simulation activities based on Computational Fluid Dynamics
(CFD) codes, extended with chemistry and mechanical models. Many questions in this field can
be handled already with standard CFD tools, like flow distribution in cleaning baths. Other
examples for such simulations are the prediction of temperature distributions in annealing
furnaces or in RF heated epi reactors.
These more recent applications will gain increasing attention as they open a similar
potential for improved physical understanding of the processes as well as for saving con-
siderable amounts of time and money for process and equipment development. As in the crystal
growth and defect modeling activities, the close collaboration of industry and research
institutes will be extremely important for such new modeling topics, to finally have them at the
same scientific level and with the same impact on industrial day to day research and
development work.
Conclusions
Numerical modeling is an integral part of today’s industrial silicon crystal growth and
wafer manufacturing R&D activities, with a variety of applications. Crystal growth simulation
with thermal and convection models, both for the CZ and the FZ method is the most well
established application. Within this field, in particular modeling of electromagnetic field
influence on melt flow has become an indispensable means for the puller design and the process
development for both methods. The defect distribution in a wafer is extremely important for
the yield and profitability of microelectronic device production lines. Therefore, various model
approaches for predicting crystal growth and wafer treatment related defects, like grown-in
voids or oxygen precipitates, have been developed and are successfully used in the industry.
New applications of numerical modeling in auxiliary processes, like wafer heat treatment steps,
epitaxial growth or wafer cleaning are being developed and successfully used in industrial
equipment and process design.
References
[1] Dornberger, E., Tomzig, E., Seidl, A., Schmitt, S., Leister, H.-J., Schmitt, Ch., Müller, G.: Thermal
Simulation of the Czochralski silicon growth process by three different models and comparison with
experiment. J. Cryst. Growth 181 (1997), 461 pp.
[2] Van den Bogaert, N., Dupret, F.: Dynamic global simulation of the Czochralski process I / II. J. Cryst.
Growth 171 (1997), pp. 65-93
[3] Kurz, M., Pusztai, A., Müller, G.: Development of a new powerful computer code CrysVUN++ especially
designed for fast simulation of bulk crystal growth processes. J. Cryst. Growth (198/199 (1999), pp. 101-
106
[4] Lipchin, A., Brown, R.A.: Hybrid finite-volume/finite element simulation of heat transfer and turbulence in
Czochralski growth of silicon. J. Cryst. Growth 216 (2000), pp. 192-203
[5] Wetzel, Th., Muiznieks, A., Mühlbauer, A., Gelfgat, Y., Gorbunov, L., Virbulis, J., Tomzig, E., von
Ammon, W.: Numerical model of turbulent CZ melt flow in the presence of AC and CUSP magnetic fields
and its verification in a laboratory facility. J. Cryst. Growth 230 (2001) pp. 81-91
[6] Lipchin, A., Brown, R.A.: Comparison of three turbulence models for simulation of melt convection in
Czochralski crystal growth of silicon. J. Cryst. Growth 205 (1999) pp. 71-91
71
[7] Krauze, A., Muiznieks, A., Mühlbauer, A., Wetzel, Th., Gorbunov, L., Pedchenko, A.: Numerical 2D
modeling of turbulent melt flow in CZ system with AC magnetic fields. Proceedings of the Intl. Sc.
Colloquium Modelling for Electromagnetic Processing, Hannover, 2003
[8] Virbulis, J., Wetzel, Th., Muiznieks, A., Hanna, B., Dornberger, E., Tomzig, E., Mühlbauer, A., von
Ammon, W.: Numerical investigation of silicon melt flow in large diameter CZ-crystal growth under the
influence of steady and dynamic magnetic fields. J. Cryst. Growth 230 (2001) pp. 92-99
[9] Evstratov, Y., Kalaev, V.V., Zhamakin, A.I., Makarov, Y. N., Abramov, A.G., Ivanov, N.G., Smirnov,
E.M., Dornberger, E., Virbulis, J., Tomzig, E., von Ammon, W.: Modeling analysis of unsteady three-
dimensional turbulent melt flow during Czochralski growth of Si crystals. J. Cryst. Growth 230 (2001) pp.
22-29
[10] Vizman, D., Friedrich, J., Müller, G.: Comparison of the predictions from 3D numerical simulation with
temperature distributions measured in Si Czochralski melts under the influence of different magnetic fields.
J. Cryst. Growth 230 (2001) pp. 73-80
[11] Enger, S., Gräbner, O., Müller, G., Breuer, M., Durst, F.: Comparison of measurements and numerical
simulations of melt convection in Czochralski crystal growth of silicon. J. Cryst. Growth 230 (2001) pp.
135-142
[12] Pedchenko, A., Gorbunov, L., Gelfgat, Y., .: Investigation of temperature field and melt flows in
large-diameter CZ silicon modelling experiments with impact of magnetic fields. Proceedings of the Intl.
Sc. Colloquium Modelling for Electromagnetic Processing, Hannover, 2003
[13] Virbulis, J.: Numerische Simulation der Phasengrenzen und Schmelzenströmung bei der Züchtung von
Siliziumeinkristallen mit dem Floating-Zone Verfahren. Dissertation, Universität Lettlands in Riga 1997
[14] Raming, G.: Modellierung des industriellen FZ-Prozesses zur Züchtung von Silizium-Einkristallen.
Dissertation, Institut für Elektrowärme, Universität Hannover 2000
[15] Mühlbauer, A.. Muiznieks, A., Virbulis, A., Lüdge, A., Riemann, H.: Interface shape, heat transfer and
fluid flow in the floating zone growth of large silicon crystals with the needle-eye technique. J. Cryst.
Growth 151 (1995), pp. 66-79
[16] Ratnieks, G., Muiznieks, A., Buligins, L., Raming, G., Mühlbauer, A., Lüdge, A., Riemann, H.: Influence
of the three dimensionality of the HF electromagnetic field on resistivity variations in Si single crystals
during FZ growth. J. Cryst. Growth 216 (2000), pp. 204-219
[17] Muiznieks, A., Raming, G., Mühlbauer, A., Virbulis, J., Hanna, B., v. Ammon, W.: Stress-induced
dislocation generation in large FZ- and CZ-silicon single crystals––numerical model and qualitative
considerations J. Cryst. Growth 230 (2001) pp. 305-313
[18] Ratnieks, G., Muiznieks, A., Mühlbauer, A.: Mathematical modelling of industrial FZ process for large
(200mm) silicon crystal growth. Proceedings of the Intl. Sc. Colloquium Modelling for Electromagnetic
Processing, Hannover, 2003
[19] Dornberger, E.: Prediction of OSF Ring Dynamics and Grown-in Voids in Czochralski Silicon Growth.
Dissertation, Universite Catholique de Louvain 1997
[20] Gilles, D., Ewe, H.: Gettering phenomena in silicon. Semiconductor Silicon 1994, Electrochemical Society
Proceedings 94-10 (1994) pp. 772
[21] Voronkov, V.V.: The mechanism of swirl defects formation in silicon. J. Cryst. Growth 59 (1982) pp. 625-
643
[22] Sinno, T., Brown, R.A., von Ammon, W., Dornberger, E.: Point Defect Dynamics and the Oxidation-
Induced Stacking Fault Ring in Czochralski-Grown Silicon Crystals. J. Electrochem. Soc. 145 (1998) pp.
302
[23] Esfanyari, J.: Modellierung und Computersimulation der Sauerstoffpräzipitation in Silicium. PhD Thesis,
TU Wien 1995
[24] von Ammon, W., Hölzl, R., Wetzel, T., Zemke, D., Raming, G., Blietz, M.: Formation of stacking faults
in nitrogen doped silicon single crystals. Proceedings of the 8
th
International Conference on Electronic
Materials, Xian, China 2002
Authors
Dr.-Ing. Wetzel, Thomas
Wacker Siltronic AG
Numerical Modeling
P.O. Box 1140
D-84479 Burghausen
E-mail: @
Dr.-Phys. Virbulis, Janis
Center for Processes’ Analyses
PAIC
Zellu Str. 8
LV-1002 Riga, Latvia
E-mail: janis@
72
2024年6月13日发(作者:针绿凝)
International Scientific Colloquium
Modelling for Electromagnetic Processing
Hannover, March 24-26, 2003
Modeling in Industrial Silicon Wafer Manufacturing - From
Crystal Growth to Device Processes
Th. Wetzel, J. Virbulis
Abstract
Silicon wafer manufacturing is one of the key processes that determine the yield and the
profitability in semiconductor device production. The present paper gives an overview on vari-
ous applications for numerical modeling in the wafer manufacturing process. It starts with ther-
mal and convection models for the crystal growth process, both by the Czochralski (CZ) and
the Floating Zone (FZ) method. Within this field, in particular modeling of electromagnetic
field influence on melt flow has become an an indispensable means for the puller design and the
process development for both methods. A further chapter is devoted to model approaches for
predicting crystal defects, like grown-in voids, self-interstitial aggregates or oxygen
precipitates. The defect modeling connect the crystal growth directly to the device
manufacturing processes, as crystal defects may be detrimental or beneficial to microelectronic
devices, produced on the silicon wafer. A last chapter points briefly to more recent applications
of numerical modeling in auxiliary processes, like wafer heat treatment steps, epitaxial growth
or wafer cleaning.
Introduction
During the last five decades, the technology for growing silicon monocrystals from the
melt, and the subsequent manufacture of silicon wafers, have become highly developed. The
quality, purity and size of today's silicon crystals and wafers have reached an outstanding level.
However, it remains time consuming and expensive to develop new processes that meet the
crystal and wafer quality requirements for devices with further decreasing design rules. The
current transition to a wafer diameter of 300 mm creates further challenges for the wafer
industry.
One of the main driving forces for the use of numerical modeling in the wafer industry
are the extremely high costs for growth furnace design and growth process development.
Thermal simulation of the global heat transfer in crystal growth furnaces contributes substan-
tially to keeping the development costs at an acceptable level. In particular with the transition
to 300 mm diameter CZ crystal growth, magnetic fields have become an important additional
means to control heat and mass transfer in the large melt volumes. Numerical modeling
facilitates the suitable design of inductor systems and helps to understand the effect of the
magnetic fields on the melt flow. However, the growth conditions do not only affect yield or
pull rate, but also the quality of the crystals. Grown-in defects like voids, self-interstitial
aggregates or oxygen precipitates can be detrimental or beneficial in subsequent process steps.
Therefore, defect engineering, i.e. the control of the formation of such defects, is an important
part of the whole wafer production. Numerical modeling helps to predict the defect formation
and behavior through crystal growth and for subsequent process steps, up to the device
processes for microelectronic components in the chip manufacturer’s production line.
67
Beside the success of the crystal growth and the defect simulation, there is an
increasing number of new applications of numerical modeling in the wafer manufacturing
industry, e.g. in process steps like wafer polishing, epitaxial layer growth or wet cleaning of the
wafers.
1. Crystal Growth
There are two major methods for producing silicon monocrystals from the melt. With
the Czochralski (CZ) method, today crystals of up to 300 mm are grown. The Floating Zone
(FZ) technology is currently scaled up to grow 200 mm crystals.
1.1 Czochralski Growth
Fig. 1 shows a longitudinal cut through a CZ growth furnace. The prediction of the
temperature field in the whole furnace and in the crystal requires a global thermal simulation,
taking into account the heat transfer by
conduction, convection and radiation.
Software tools for the conduction and
radiation calculation along with the pre-
diction of the melt-crystal interface are avai-
lable from different institutes [1, 2, 3]. They
are based on 2D axisymmetric models, em-
ploy view factor approaches for the
radiation treatment and are based on the
Finite Element Method (FEM) or the Finite
Volume Method (FVM). Some of these
codes allow the reproduction of transient
growth processes [2].
With increasing melt volumes and
crystal diameters, the consideration of the
melt convection has become more im-
portant. The melt flow in large diameter CZ
crucibles - today diameters of up to 32” with
loads of up to 450 kg are used - is characte-
rized by time dependent, three dimensional
processes. The time needed for a fully
transient, three-dimensional simulation of
Fig. 1: Schematic layout of an industrial CZ
melt flow in a crucible of the mentioned size
puller and simulated temperature distribution
however, still prevents their application for
(left)
industrial engineering purposes. Therefore,
2D axisymmetric steady state models have been developed, that reproduce the most important
features of the 3D flow, but do still provide reasonably short calculation time [4, 5]. One of the
most critical parts in any CZ melt flow simulation, both 2D and 3D, is the consideration of
turbulence. The 2D simulation tools usually employ k-ε or LowRe k-ε or k-ω models. Such
tools require careful experimental verification and modification based on comparisons with
experiments [5, 6, 7]. A model proposed in [8] provided good agreement of the simulated
melt-crystal interface shapes with measured ones for 200 mm crystals. 3D time dependent
simulations with LES turbulence models [9] and simulations close to DNS [10, 11] are used to
further develop the understanding of the flow behavior and to improve less time consuming
simulation models. One goal of such attempts is the global modeling of oxygen transport in the
68
CZ furnace, which is extremely sensitive towards any lack of precision in the turbulence
modeling.
Another aspect, closely related to reliable melt flow prediction, is the modeling of
magnetic field influence. In 300 mm CZ growth, different types of alternating (AC) magnetic
fields as well as static (DC) magnetic fields are used. The incorporation of the melt flow
models into the global heat transfer simulation tools facilitates direct consideration of the effect
of such fields on the temperature distribution in the crystal and all coupled phenomena, like
point defect dynamics. A 2D axisymmetric model approach for the AC and DC magnetic field
effect on the silicon melt is described in [5]. The model has been verified with experimental
results from a CZ model setup with various magnetic fields [7, 12].
1.2 Floating Zone Growth
Fig. 2 shows a longitudinal cut
through an FZ growth setup [13]. For the
numerical simulation of Floating Zone
growth there is a complete model chain
necessary, starting with the prediction of the
phase boundaries at feed rod, molten zone
and crystal, based on RF field influence and
heat transfer [14]. A second part of the
model chain is covering the prediction of the
transient melt flow and heat transfer based on
2D [15] and 3D [16] approaches. Based on
the melt flow calculation results, the dopant
transport can be simulated, yielding finally
the macroscopic and microscopic resistivity
distributions in grown wafers. The current
development of 200 mm FZ crystal growth
processes has been substantially supported by
the use of such simulation models.
Beyond these applications, the
influence of additional low frequency
Fig. 2: Schematic layout of a Floating Zone
inductors has been modeled [14] and
setup with simulated features and FEM mesh
considerations about the stress induced dislocation generation have been started [17]. A
recently developed improved phase boundary simulation model is presented in [18].
3. Defect Modeling
There are different types of defects in silicon wafers, which are related to the crystal
growth conditions and the thermal history of the crystal and wafer. During the solidification
process, intrinsic point defects, namely vacancies and silicon self interstitials, are incorporated
into the crystal. These intrinsic point defects form grown-in defects during cooling down from
melting to room temperature. Impurity atoms can also be incorporated into the growing
crystal, later forming precipitates or other defects. The most common of these impurities is
oxygen, which is dissolved from the silica crucible in CZ processes and transported through the
melt to the crystallization front.
69
Three types of defects in CZ crystals will be
mentioned here specifically: grown-in octahedral voids [19]
formed by the aggregation of vacancies (Fig. 3), oxide
precipitates [20] and the OSF ring [19].
Whether vacancy or self-interstitial related defects
are found in a CZ crystal or crystal region, depends on the
value v/G in that region at the crystallization interface during
solidification (v being the pull rate, G the temperature
gradient at the solid/liquid interface) [19, 21]. In addition to
determining these quantities from the thermal simulation,
models are used to directly describe the point defect
dynamics, i.e. the diffusive and convective transport of these
defects during crystal growth as well as their annihilation by
recombination [22]. The combination of such simulation
Fig.3: Octahedral void in an
models with the thermal simulation results, in particular the
as-grown silicon crystal [19]
transient temperature field in the crystal, allows to design
the growth furnace and the growth process in such a way, that grown crystals show a desired
defect species.
Furthermore, especially for vacancy rich crystals, that are for the production
of memory chips, it is necessary to ensure a specific size and density of the grown-in voids.
Simulation models have been developed, that describe the formation of such defects from
vacancies [19]. The size of the grown in voids depends strongly on the cooling rate in a
specific temperature interval during cooling down. Therefore, these models do also need the
thermal history of the crystal as well as the results of the point defect models. Fig. 4 shows
simulated size distributions of voids in fast and slow cooled CZ crystals. The void formation
models are also used to predict the impact of wafer heat treatment steps on size and density of
the voids.
An important part of defect modeling is devoted to the behavior of oxygen in CZ
silicon. As oxide precipitates are used as centers for internal gettering [20], models have been
developed to predict the size and in particular the density of such defects in CZ crystals and
wafers [23]. Another well known defect phenomenon is the so called OSF ring, appearing on
the wafer surface after
wet oxidation. The
nature and formation
of the OSF ring has
been studied by many
authors (see [19] for
further ref.). How-
ever, there is ongoing
research activity in
this field, as there are
complex interactions
of oxygen precipi-
tation with other point
defects or impurity
atoms in the growing
crystal, e.g. Nitrogen,
Fig. 4: Simulated size distributions of voids in crystals with different
that the
cooling rates
width of the OSF ring
70
[24].
3. Modeling for Wafer Processing Steps
Following crystal growth, there are several process steps in a wafer production line. It
starts with cutting of the ingots, goes through slicing, etching, polishing and ends with final
cleaning of the wafers. Inbetween there can be several other steps like lapping, thermal
treatment or epitaxial layer growth. In particular in the areas of etching, cleaning and epitaxial
layer growth there are several simulation activities based on Computational Fluid Dynamics
(CFD) codes, extended with chemistry and mechanical models. Many questions in this field can
be handled already with standard CFD tools, like flow distribution in cleaning baths. Other
examples for such simulations are the prediction of temperature distributions in annealing
furnaces or in RF heated epi reactors.
These more recent applications will gain increasing attention as they open a similar
potential for improved physical understanding of the processes as well as for saving con-
siderable amounts of time and money for process and equipment development. As in the crystal
growth and defect modeling activities, the close collaboration of industry and research
institutes will be extremely important for such new modeling topics, to finally have them at the
same scientific level and with the same impact on industrial day to day research and
development work.
Conclusions
Numerical modeling is an integral part of today’s industrial silicon crystal growth and
wafer manufacturing R&D activities, with a variety of applications. Crystal growth simulation
with thermal and convection models, both for the CZ and the FZ method is the most well
established application. Within this field, in particular modeling of electromagnetic field
influence on melt flow has become an indispensable means for the puller design and the process
development for both methods. The defect distribution in a wafer is extremely important for
the yield and profitability of microelectronic device production lines. Therefore, various model
approaches for predicting crystal growth and wafer treatment related defects, like grown-in
voids or oxygen precipitates, have been developed and are successfully used in the industry.
New applications of numerical modeling in auxiliary processes, like wafer heat treatment steps,
epitaxial growth or wafer cleaning are being developed and successfully used in industrial
equipment and process design.
References
[1] Dornberger, E., Tomzig, E., Seidl, A., Schmitt, S., Leister, H.-J., Schmitt, Ch., Müller, G.: Thermal
Simulation of the Czochralski silicon growth process by three different models and comparison with
experiment. J. Cryst. Growth 181 (1997), 461 pp.
[2] Van den Bogaert, N., Dupret, F.: Dynamic global simulation of the Czochralski process I / II. J. Cryst.
Growth 171 (1997), pp. 65-93
[3] Kurz, M., Pusztai, A., Müller, G.: Development of a new powerful computer code CrysVUN++ especially
designed for fast simulation of bulk crystal growth processes. J. Cryst. Growth (198/199 (1999), pp. 101-
106
[4] Lipchin, A., Brown, R.A.: Hybrid finite-volume/finite element simulation of heat transfer and turbulence in
Czochralski growth of silicon. J. Cryst. Growth 216 (2000), pp. 192-203
[5] Wetzel, Th., Muiznieks, A., Mühlbauer, A., Gelfgat, Y., Gorbunov, L., Virbulis, J., Tomzig, E., von
Ammon, W.: Numerical model of turbulent CZ melt flow in the presence of AC and CUSP magnetic fields
and its verification in a laboratory facility. J. Cryst. Growth 230 (2001) pp. 81-91
[6] Lipchin, A., Brown, R.A.: Comparison of three turbulence models for simulation of melt convection in
Czochralski crystal growth of silicon. J. Cryst. Growth 205 (1999) pp. 71-91
71
[7] Krauze, A., Muiznieks, A., Mühlbauer, A., Wetzel, Th., Gorbunov, L., Pedchenko, A.: Numerical 2D
modeling of turbulent melt flow in CZ system with AC magnetic fields. Proceedings of the Intl. Sc.
Colloquium Modelling for Electromagnetic Processing, Hannover, 2003
[8] Virbulis, J., Wetzel, Th., Muiznieks, A., Hanna, B., Dornberger, E., Tomzig, E., Mühlbauer, A., von
Ammon, W.: Numerical investigation of silicon melt flow in large diameter CZ-crystal growth under the
influence of steady and dynamic magnetic fields. J. Cryst. Growth 230 (2001) pp. 92-99
[9] Evstratov, Y., Kalaev, V.V., Zhamakin, A.I., Makarov, Y. N., Abramov, A.G., Ivanov, N.G., Smirnov,
E.M., Dornberger, E., Virbulis, J., Tomzig, E., von Ammon, W.: Modeling analysis of unsteady three-
dimensional turbulent melt flow during Czochralski growth of Si crystals. J. Cryst. Growth 230 (2001) pp.
22-29
[10] Vizman, D., Friedrich, J., Müller, G.: Comparison of the predictions from 3D numerical simulation with
temperature distributions measured in Si Czochralski melts under the influence of different magnetic fields.
J. Cryst. Growth 230 (2001) pp. 73-80
[11] Enger, S., Gräbner, O., Müller, G., Breuer, M., Durst, F.: Comparison of measurements and numerical
simulations of melt convection in Czochralski crystal growth of silicon. J. Cryst. Growth 230 (2001) pp.
135-142
[12] Pedchenko, A., Gorbunov, L., Gelfgat, Y., .: Investigation of temperature field and melt flows in
large-diameter CZ silicon modelling experiments with impact of magnetic fields. Proceedings of the Intl.
Sc. Colloquium Modelling for Electromagnetic Processing, Hannover, 2003
[13] Virbulis, J.: Numerische Simulation der Phasengrenzen und Schmelzenströmung bei der Züchtung von
Siliziumeinkristallen mit dem Floating-Zone Verfahren. Dissertation, Universität Lettlands in Riga 1997
[14] Raming, G.: Modellierung des industriellen FZ-Prozesses zur Züchtung von Silizium-Einkristallen.
Dissertation, Institut für Elektrowärme, Universität Hannover 2000
[15] Mühlbauer, A.. Muiznieks, A., Virbulis, A., Lüdge, A., Riemann, H.: Interface shape, heat transfer and
fluid flow in the floating zone growth of large silicon crystals with the needle-eye technique. J. Cryst.
Growth 151 (1995), pp. 66-79
[16] Ratnieks, G., Muiznieks, A., Buligins, L., Raming, G., Mühlbauer, A., Lüdge, A., Riemann, H.: Influence
of the three dimensionality of the HF electromagnetic field on resistivity variations in Si single crystals
during FZ growth. J. Cryst. Growth 216 (2000), pp. 204-219
[17] Muiznieks, A., Raming, G., Mühlbauer, A., Virbulis, J., Hanna, B., v. Ammon, W.: Stress-induced
dislocation generation in large FZ- and CZ-silicon single crystals––numerical model and qualitative
considerations J. Cryst. Growth 230 (2001) pp. 305-313
[18] Ratnieks, G., Muiznieks, A., Mühlbauer, A.: Mathematical modelling of industrial FZ process for large
(200mm) silicon crystal growth. Proceedings of the Intl. Sc. Colloquium Modelling for Electromagnetic
Processing, Hannover, 2003
[19] Dornberger, E.: Prediction of OSF Ring Dynamics and Grown-in Voids in Czochralski Silicon Growth.
Dissertation, Universite Catholique de Louvain 1997
[20] Gilles, D., Ewe, H.: Gettering phenomena in silicon. Semiconductor Silicon 1994, Electrochemical Society
Proceedings 94-10 (1994) pp. 772
[21] Voronkov, V.V.: The mechanism of swirl defects formation in silicon. J. Cryst. Growth 59 (1982) pp. 625-
643
[22] Sinno, T., Brown, R.A., von Ammon, W., Dornberger, E.: Point Defect Dynamics and the Oxidation-
Induced Stacking Fault Ring in Czochralski-Grown Silicon Crystals. J. Electrochem. Soc. 145 (1998) pp.
302
[23] Esfanyari, J.: Modellierung und Computersimulation der Sauerstoffpräzipitation in Silicium. PhD Thesis,
TU Wien 1995
[24] von Ammon, W., Hölzl, R., Wetzel, T., Zemke, D., Raming, G., Blietz, M.: Formation of stacking faults
in nitrogen doped silicon single crystals. Proceedings of the 8
th
International Conference on Electronic
Materials, Xian, China 2002
Authors
Dr.-Ing. Wetzel, Thomas
Wacker Siltronic AG
Numerical Modeling
P.O. Box 1140
D-84479 Burghausen
E-mail: @
Dr.-Phys. Virbulis, Janis
Center for Processes’ Analyses
PAIC
Zellu Str. 8
LV-1002 Riga, Latvia
E-mail: janis@
72